The previous post on breakouts and failed signals discussed the significance of futures price breakouts from long term trading ranges. In terms of coffee futures, this suggested a powerful bull run to come. That post also discussed the relevance of consistently accurate indicators giving a false signal. Both of these events occurred in coffee futures just 3 weeks ago, and since then coffee futures have made a run up to $1.43 as of today.

And now we are left in a very curious situation. Coffee futures, like most other commodities have natural production and consumption cycles year on year known as seasonality, or the tendency for futures prices to rise and fall at certain times of the year. Coffee futures have the single strongest seasonal tendency of all commodities in June and July, and it doesn’t work in our favor. The tendency is for coffee prices to crash. And I do mean crash, and not simply correct. The chart below is a seasonal chart of coffee futures.

In the last 30 years there may have only been 2 occasions where coffee futures prices have not ended lower by the end of June than they were the end of May, and it is typical for them to end significantly lower. This consistency in price collapse is a result of the onset of the Brazilian harvest in May and June, as Brazil is the largest producer of Arabica coffee. This force is usually strong enough, even in times of tight supply and demand, to force a corrective downward adjustment in prices. And the question on everyone’s mind is, “Are we going to experience the same this year.”

There are occasions in commodity trading of course where prices reject their seasonal tendency. When this occurs it’s usually as sign of very strong underlying fundamentals, and you’d be well advised to go with the flow. This is a similar concept to the Hounds of the Baskervilles concept discussed in the previous post. When something ought to occur and it doesn’t, that in itself is an important indicator and perhaps even more significant than your average futures price indicators as it implies the strength of forces that are, at least at present, imperceptible and dominant.

Coffee futures were coming dangerously close to flashing bearish divergence on several indicators, but after today’s strong move up, that has changed. I was hoping for a clear sign of bearishness, as that would have ceiled the deal for siding with the bears short term. Indicators would have corroborated the seasonal tendency for prices to fall. But that is not happening, which leaves us in a very precarious situation. The seasonal tendency is for coffee futures prices to fall, the current trend is clearly up and gaining momentum, with no technical sign of waning.

This market has absolutely everything going for it at the moment, with the exception of the typical seasonal downturn. Coffee fundamentals are incredibly bullish, with Columbian price differentials somewhere between 70 and 90 cents above the futures price. This is a record and when similar things happened in the past it’s resulted in higher futures prices. Columbia, Vietnam, and Brazil are all looking at smaller crops this year, and it will be a year before producers will have a chance of alleviating tightness. Prices have broken out of a five month range while simultaneously breaching the 1 year downward trend line.

Despite this overwhelming case to be long the market, prices are feeling toppy, at least short term. Those of you who have been with me for a few months are in this market from $1.15 and have already made 300% profit (based on margin requirements) per futures contract. This is a $10,000 profit with an initial risk of $1,000. If you’ve purchased long dated options then your profit is less, but still somewhere in the 200 to 300% range. And while I’m not suggesting you bail out on the bull, it is time to tighten stop losses on futures and to take a little profit on options holdings. After a correction we may consider reentering in full and adding to the position. So in sum, let the bull ride, but be cautiously optimistic. This seasonal tendency can come out of nowhere with great force.